The oldest child of John Baptist Wills, Sr. and Anne Livers, Anne Prudence Wills was named for her mother Anne and her mother’s grandmother Prudence Cooper (d. 1757).
She was clearly a competent manager since she is named as co-executor in the 1796 will of her grandmother Mary Livers. Her grandmother thought less well of Anne’s husband, excluding him from any “power to dispose or intermeddle” with her inheritance. In that same will, she is bequeathed two Negro women, “to be in noways liable to her said husband’s debts, disposal or incombrance.”
Her husband mentioned was her distant cousin James Thompson (d.1795, son of William Thompson), whom she married September 17, 1786 (the Thompson family bible is the source for this and most births, deaths and marriages of this family). Family records state that James served for a four year period in the American Revolution. There is also a record of a transfer of a parcel of land known as “Thompson’s Neglect” from George Thompson to James Thompson in 1793. This parcel was included in a survey of Forest Grove made in 1856 for their son Col. Francis Thompson.
James is listed in the Census of 1790 of Charles County with a household of two white males under the age of sixteen, three white females and six slaves. When James Thompson was named as executor for his sister Elizabeth’s estate in 1790, John Baptist Wills was one of his securities. When he died intestate in Charles County in 1795, Ann was the initial administratrix of her husband’s estate (inventories Aug 1795 at £92). By the time of her accounting on Feb. 27, 1797, she was named “Anne Prudence Smith” and her new husband Mathew Smith was co-administrator of the April 1798 accounting.
The Thompson family bible contains an entry that Ann Prudence Smith “departed this life Ash Wednesday February 16, 1820.”
Children of Anne Prudence Wills and James Thompson (vital dates from the Thompson Bible):
1.1) Justinian Thompson, born November 26, 1787, prob. died young
1.2) Col. William Thompson (1790-1853), m. Mary Grace Davis
He was born September 25, 1789. He was commissioned an ensign in Captain John Matthews’ company of Regiment No. 1 of the Maryland Militia in Charles County in 1810. A successful manager and landowner, he was named as sole executor in the 1832 will of his aunt Mary Aliana Wills. She gives him “500 dollars for services rendered to me by him in the management of my pecuniary affairs—my nephew William Thompson has a debt of long-standing against my estate which I direct to be paid.” He had the resources to be an active member of his uncle John B. Wills, Jr’s’ fox hunts.
On Nov. 15, 1842, he married the much younger Mary Grace (probably daughter of Thomas Andrew and Elizabeth Grace Davis), who was probably his second wife.
On 19 June 1849, he bought the historic property which was then associated with the Thompsons and Wills’ for the subsequent century. With the name “Mattawoman”, it had been the family home of George Mason’s wife Anne Eilbeck and the Masons lived there while building Gunston Hall across the river.
Visits there were recorded by George Washington who also lived across the Potomac. It was from the widow and daughter of George Mason’s son William Mason that William Thompson purchased “402 acres, 1 rod, and 28 perches of land known as ‘Mason’s Amendment’ for six thousand dollars”.
Thompson changed the name of the property to “Araby”, which continues as its name until the present. When William Thompson died four years later, he apparently had no children, for he left it to his brother Francis Thompson, who soon gave it to his daughter Anne Thompson Wills.
William Thompson appears in the 1850 Census aged 59 with $15,000 in real estate and 35 slaves. His wife Mary Grace is listed aged 32. She died a month later on October 31, 1850 (her tombstone is with her husband at Pomfret).
The Marlboro Gazette of March 2, 1853 reports that “Col. William Thompson, for many years a member of the firm of Thompson & Spalding” died “at his residence (Araby) in Charles county, in the 63rd year of his age” on Feb. 21 and is buried under a handsome obelisk at St. Joseph’s in Pomfret.
His gravestone at St. Joseph’s Church in Pomfret says he was born Dec. 3, 1791 and died Dec. 26, 1876. He was a Militia captain in 1813. In the 1832 will of his aunt Mary Aliana Wills, he is bequeathed $200.
On May 29, 1827, he and Charlotte H. Johnson were married by Rev. J. V. Wiseman (pastor of St. Mary’s, Bryantown). She was the daughter of family friend Col. Alexander Johnson (John Baptist Wills, Jr was one of the securities for his estate in 1822 — see more below). She was born July 12, 1808 and died young on August 12, 1839 and is also buried at Pomfret.
In the late 1840s, Col. Francis Thompson was President of the Trustees of Pomfret Church when the new church was built there. Among the 40 other subscribers were Greens, Hamiltons, Jenkings, Mitchells, Pyes, Spaldings, Stones, and Charles Wills, Charles H. Wills, Joseph Wills, and “Mr. Wills”. He was also a promoter of horse racing during the 1840s.
In the 1830 census, he had 19 slaves; in 1840, 12 slaves. In the 1850 census, he is recorded with real estate valued at $10,000 and 25 slaves (7 adults, 18 children). His three surviving teenage children are also recorded, with Mary C (aged 16) and Marcellus (aged 13) marked as attending school.
In 1853, his brother William died and, “he left about fifty thousand dollars worth of property which goes to Col. Frank, he is now a rich man” (1853 letter of John L. Johnson). This included the Araby estate. By 1856 his plantation known as Forest Grove was comprised of 563 acres. It seems that not long after that he divided up his property among the three daughters and one son who survived to adulthood. Araby was given (in 1856?) to his daughter Anna, and “Forest Grove” to his son Marcellus.
By the 1860 census, he had retired, and his occupation was listed as “Gentleman” with only $500 in real estate, $1000 in personal property, two older female slaves. He was living with Marcellus (“Planter”, $10,000 real estate, $5000 personal, 9 slaves) and on the next property was his daughter Amelia Stonestreet and her husband Nicholas (“Planter”, $8000 real estate, $26850 personal, 36 slaves). A Confederate sympathizer, he presided over a meeting in December 1860 censuring those who had supported the candidacy of Lincoln and Hamlin in the presidential elections of that year.
In the 1870 census after the war, he was still living with Marcellus, and the farms were valued at $10,000 but with only $1000 personal property together. In 1869, his brother-in-law John Johnson wrote: “Col. Thompson is still living. He is 78 years old and looks well for all his years.” In fact, he lived to the age of 85, when he died on December 26, 1876 at Araby, the home of his daughter Anna Maria Wills.
In his will, Francis Thompson writes that he had deeded all his property to his children many years before, reserving to himself a life estate and some stocks for a pension. After stating, “whereas my affection is equal to all my children, but I believe my son Marcellus Thompson is really more in need than any of the others”, he then bequeaths the remaining stocks and money to Marcellus.” His children were:
1.3.1) Anna Maria Thompson (1828/9-1898) m. 1850 cousin Charles H. Wills. They had six children but none married.
1.3.2) James William Thompson (May 29, 1831—Jan. 16, 1833)
1.3.3) Amelia Dyer “Kit” Thompson (Dec 24, 1832—Feb 18, 1906). In 1853, her uncle John L. Johnson wrote to a brother in Alabama, “Amelia Dyer Thompson, named after her grandmother, is to be married to John Wills, nephew of old John B. Wills, who was so very intimate and a great friend of our poor father—you knew him.” He must have meant the engagement was to John B. Wills (1831-1859), grandson of John B. Wills, Jr. but it was apparently never consummated.
Rather she and Nicholas Stonestreet (c. 1828-1890) were married on Nov. 9, 1859 by his relative Fr. Charles Stonestreet SJ. Nicholas Stonestreet was a lawyer in Port Tobacco. In 1874, he sought $2050 compensation from the government for the use and damage to 125 acres of “Shadeland” owned by Amelia D. Stonestreet during the period 1861-64. The Quartermaster-General reported that Nicholas Stonestreet had not been loyal to the Government and recommended against the claim, but the claim was repeatedly submitted, and finally by their son Charles H. Stonestreet to the Senate in 1910. Their children were Francis X., Charles H., and Mary F. The family is buried at St. Ignatius, Chapel Point.
1.3.4) Mary Cecilia Thompson (1834 — 1913 ) m. Dr. Robert Digges (1828—1901), former partner of her cousin Dr. Francis H. Wills, on June 1, 1858. She and her husband are buried at St. Ignatius, Chapel Point. Their children were Wm. Joseph Digges (1860-1915, m. Cath. Sellman), Mary (1864-1923), Catherine Neale (1865-1897), Robert I. (1867-1916), Bernard C. (b.1869), A. Caroline (b. 1872), Arthur S. (1874-1905), Amelia W. (b.1878).
1.3.5) Francis William Thompson (Aug. 6, 1836 — May 14, 1845), buried at Pomfret.
1.3.6) Robert “Bob” Marcellus Thompson (March 21, 1838 —Nov. 15, 1898) m. Mary Josephine Green (Sept. 17, 1840 -Nov. 18, 1911) on May 19, 1863 at Eutaw, then the home of the Dement family. He was Register of Wills for Charles County for a period and was a surveyor and an insurance broker. During the 1890’s the family home “Forest Grove” burned and economic circumstances forced the family to relocate to Baltimore. Six of their children survived their mother: Robert Francis, William Joseph, Anna Josephine (Burch), Mary Elizabeth, Corita Cecilia (Sharrer), Bernard Marcellus.
In a letter dated 7 Jan. 1868, Catherine Johnson Burch gave the family news to her nephew in Alabama, “Your cousin Bob Thompson is married and living at the old place. He married a Miss Green, daughter of Caleb Green and granddaughter of Col. Green whom your poor father knew. Kit and Mary C. are married also. Kit married a Mr. Stonestreet near Port Tobacco.”
In an 1899 letter to Georgetown College, Charles Hoffman Wills reported: “My uncle Marcellus Thompson left G.T. I think in ’53; he did not graduate from G.T. He went to Emmitsburg and afterwards studied surveying; his whole life however was spent on the estate of his father, “Forest Grove”. He was a member of the sodality at G.T and made his first communion there. I have heard him say that no act of his life gave him more pleasure, nor could he look back to any action with more satisfaction. His career as a Confederate soldier was a short one because he was caught by the Yankees almost as soon as he crossed the Potomac to Virginia, was then taken to Washington and put in the old Capitol, in which place he was confined for several months. He was once elected Register of Wills on the Independent Ticket. He died last November.”
Charles Hoffman Wills also mentioned his “Aunt Kit (Mrs. Amelia Stonestreet)”: “Her husband Capt. Nicholas Stonestreet graduated about 18– at the age of 17. He was, I think, captain of a cavalry company in this county some years ago — thus his title. He practiced law here for a good many years and figured in politics to some extent. He died some ten or twelve years ago. His half-brother Mr. Harris Stonestreet was at G.T. for four years but graduated at Princeton. His whole life, I think, was spent on his farm. He has been dead four or five years ago.”
1.4) Ann Maria Thompson, born October 1, 1793 — known only from the bible record of her birth.